The Billionaire's Vinegar: The Mystery of the World's Most Expensive Bottle of Wine

The Billionaire's Vinegar: The Mystery of the World's Most Expensive Bottle of Wine by Benjamin Wallace, 2009, Three Rivers Press

What is the book about?

This isn't some snooty book about wine; it's a captivating true-crime story set in the world of high-end wine collecting. It’s a tale of Thomas Jefferson, a German wine collector with a penchant for the dramatic, and a whole lot of questions. If you thought wine was just fermented grape juice, this book will make you think again—and maybe question everything you thought you knew about provenance, authenticity, and the lengths people will go to for a piece of history (or a hefty profit).

The Billionaire's Vinegar centers around a bottle of 1787 Château Lafite, purportedly owned by Thomas Jefferson, that was sold at auction for a record-breaking £105,000 (around $160,000 at the time). The book unravels the intricate story of this bottle, tracing its journey from a dusty cellar in Paris to the auction block at Christie's. Along the way, Wallace introduces a colorful cast of characters, including Hardy Rodenstock, the flamboyant German wine collector who "discovered" the bottle, and a network of experts, collectors, and potential fraudsters. The narrative explores the complexities of wine authentication, the psychology of collecting, and the allure of owning a piece of history—even if that history might be a fabrication. It's a real whodunnit, but with more tannins and fewer fingerprints.


Key Takeaways

The Fragility of Authenticity: The book highlights how easily even experts can be fooled when it comes to verifying the authenticity of rare and valuable items. It makes you realize that sometimes, a fancy-looking bottle and a good story are all it takes.

The Psychology of Collecting: Wallace delves into the motivations behind collecting, exploring the desire for status, the thrill of the hunt, and the emotional connection people form with their collections. It's a reminder that sometimes, the value is in the story, not just the object.

The Importance of Provenance: The book underscores the crucial role of provenance (the documented history of an object's ownership) in establishing authenticity and value. It's like a wine's family tree, and if there are missing branches, things get suspicious.

The Shady Side of the Wine World: The Billionaire's Vinegar exposes the potential for fraud and deception in the high-stakes world of fine wine collecting. It's a reminder that even in the most refined circles, there's room for a bit of mischief.


Would I recommend reading it?

This book is a recommended read because it's such an enjoyable read. It has a captivating and well-researched story that transcends the world of wine. I went into it knowing absolutely nothing about wine, and now I have a better understanding as to why it has had such a grip on the world for so long. It does a fantastic job of teaching you about tannins, history, and fairly scientific topics without it feeling academic. 

It's also a fascinating exploration of human nature, the pursuit of wealth and status, and the blurry lines between truth and deception. It's also just a really good story, told with wit and engaging prose. It's the kind of book that will have you turning pages late into the night, even if you don't know a Bordeaux from a Burgundy. I certainly don't. 


Who I Would Recommend This Book To

  • Wine lovers (obviously).
  • History buffs, particularly those interested in Thomas Jefferson and the 18th century.
  • True crime fans.
  • Anyone interested in the world of collecting and the psychology behind it.
  • People who enjoy a good, well-told story with a dash of mystery.

Expect a captivating narrative filled with colorful characters, historical context, and a healthy dose of suspense. It's a story that will make you think twice about the next time you see a ridiculously expensive bottle of wine – is it a historical treasure, or just a very elaborate hoax? Either way, it's a great read.


*This post contains affiliate links, which means I get a small commission if you make a purchase through my links. Don't worry, it doesn't cost you anything extra, and it helps keep the lights on here. Plus, I only recommend stuff I actually like. I'm not trying to sell you a bridge here... unless it's a really cool bridge

Comments